Recarving Rushmore: Ranking the Presidents on Peace, Prosperity, and Liberty #2020

Recarving Rushmore: Ranking the Presidents on Peace, Prosperity, and Liberty By Ivan Eland Recarving Rushmore Ranking the Presidents on Peace Prosperity and Liberty Profiling each president on the merits of their policies and on the core principles of peace prosperity and liberty this ranking system takes a distinctly new approach Historians and scholars have
  • Title: Recarving Rushmore: Ranking the Presidents on Peace, Prosperity, and Liberty
  • Author: Ivan Eland
  • ISBN: 9781598130225
  • Page: 493
  • Format: Hardcover
  • Recarving Rushmore: Ranking the Presidents on Peace, Prosperity, and Liberty By Ivan Eland Profiling each president on the merits of their policies and on the core principles of peace, prosperity, and liberty, this ranking system takes a distinctly new approach Historians and scholars have long tended to respect the war heroes and men who have succeeded in expanding the power of the executive office However, this new examination cuts through longstanding biasProfiling each president on the merits of their policies and on the core principles of peace, prosperity, and liberty, this ranking system takes a distinctly new approach Historians and scholars have long tended to respect the war heroes and men who have succeeded in expanding the power of the executive office However, this new examination cuts through longstanding bias and political rhetoric to offer a new nonpartisan system of ranking that is based purely on strength of policies and adherence to the Founding Father s guidelines for limited government These rankings will surprise most and enlighten even acknowledged experts on the presidency.
    Recarving Rushmore: Ranking the Presidents on Peace, Prosperity, and Liberty By Ivan Eland
    • [☆ Recarving Rushmore: Ranking the Presidents on Peace, Prosperity, and Liberty || ☆ PDF Read by ´ Ivan Eland]
      Ivan Eland

    About "Ivan Eland"

    1. Ivan Eland

      Ivan Eland Is a well-known author, some of his books are a fascination for readers like in the Recarving Rushmore: Ranking the Presidents on Peace, Prosperity, and Liberty book, this is one of the most wanted Ivan Eland author readers around the world.

    595 thoughts on “Recarving Rushmore: Ranking the Presidents on Peace, Prosperity, and Liberty”

    1. I heard about this book because it was referenced in Ron Paul s The Revolution A Manifesto.What this book does is rank the presidents on, as the title would indicate, peace, prosperity, and liberty The introduction describes exactly what criteria go into these rankings and also how they differ from the criteria used by other analysts rankings.This book isn t really partisan if anything it s Libertarian but not even that It simply takes a different look at the actions of presidents with some poss [...]


    2. The author was too ambitious in writing this book A proper attempt at any form of objectivity in ranking individuals needs to stem from discussion by a group of diverse people, not just one man who s only claim to objectivitity is a lack of political identification with the two main parties discussed.In the end his biases show, and a na ve but intelligent reader would have a hard time developing reasonable judgements of their own on past presidents.That being said, it is always good to read othe [...]


    3. Presidential rankings tend to favor those who were most active, reigning during a crisis or creating expansive new programs that alter the nation s fortunes What of the peaceful administrators, however, those men who fulfilled their oaths expertly and restrained themselves from intervening unnecessarily in the lives of the people, or in the affairs of other countries Recarving Rush ranks the presidents based on their performance in peace, prosperity, and liberty, and the results challenge conven [...]


    4. This is a great American history book Each president chapter could be read in isolation, or you can read it front to back like I did The author reiterates without boring you or wasting words what the significance of presidential policies were when they carry through multiple administrations There are many events in American history that will either be new to you or have you thinking deeply about them If every American read this book, we would have a better informed populace with a healthy dose [...]


    5. HA HA HA HA This book was FUN nee I almost wet myself laughing.Let me see if I got this right Mister Libertarian writer from some tax dodge called the Independent Institute says that Jimmy Carter is the 8th best president based on policies that led to peace and prosperity James Earl Jr is nudged in there right between a guy named Washington No 7 and a guy named Eisenhower No 9 I can t stop laughing.And who makes the bad list Reagan, FDR, and Lincoln.I have a bit of a Libertarian in me, but come [...]


    6. Eye opening evaluation of 40 presidents from George Washington to George W Bush William Henry Harrison and John Garfield are omitted as their terms were so short Popular and scholarly opinion of who the best and worst presidents were is turned upside down by the author, who bases his rankings on how well each man upheld the principles of peace, prosperity and liberty Indeed, Dr Eland makes an excellent case for recarving Rush.


    7. Though I don t completely agree with the Author s criteria for a great presidency, I think that this book offers an interesting perspective It is quite a bit editorialized, but each write up contains interesting and concise facts about American history.


    8. I really like the idea of this book, and it does contain some interesting points of view and tidbits I also really like that the author factored a president s treatment of Native Americans into his ranking, which other ranking schemes seem to ignore But onto the stuff I didn t like In discussing how a president has taken actions to infringe on personal liberties or that will lead to a disruption in peace or prosperity, the author gives his own opinion on what the president should have done, but [...]


    9. Recarving Rush Ranking the Presidents on Peace, Prosperity, and Liberty by Ivan Eland is the type of book I want to see A look at the previous presidents that doesn t pull punches and actually examines the president not by what was done but rather what could have been done Mr Eland starts by making some ground breaking statements, claiming that historians judge presidents incorrectly, they tend to focus on activism from presidents and reward wartime presidents, ignoring the fact that many of the [...]


    10. The author claims that he will rate Presidents on a objective scale then typically used and then proceed to demonstrate that objectivity is not really in consideration here He excuses one President from being responsible for Congressional acts and vilifies another He makes claims about the Constitution that are not supported by that document as well as claims about the founder s intent that are not supported by the evidence they left He seems to be using a single source for many of his profiles [...]


    11. This book consists of short histories of each president up to George W Bush The chapters are really too short and do not contain enough information to come to the conclusions of the author He also repeats much information from previous to subsequent chapters almost as if he copied and pasted passages.



    12. Best history book I have read You will learn a lot about wars and conflicts in the 1800s that you probably never knew about.


    13. Great book For those scoffers who can t begin to understand how a president like Jimmy Carter got a high rating by Eland, as opposed to say, Ronald Reagan, FDR, Woodrow Wilson,George W etc it s important to remember Eland is not rating presidents like most modern historians have major war, most legislation passed, greatest social impact great president Instead he is rating them like a Libertarian would In other words, how well did they do their job as described in the U.S Constitution His explan [...]


    14. A revisionist list of the past 43 presidents with rankings that change the perspective of what makes a sucessful president Interesting and full of details told from the idea that radically changing policies, tax codes, and startings wars are not necessisarily great things to do Puts the executive branch in perspective by comparing how much out of bounds the historical favorites stepped The book celebrates all those whatshisface presidents like Cleveland and Tyler.


    15. Wow This book is clearly the definitive base to a Libertarian foreign policy Eland makes a strong case for non interventionism While, like most Libertarian raters, he is pretty critical of modern Presidents, unlike others, he accepts the inherent challenges of the Executive office And I think he understands that building a new Mt Rush would be a horrendous waste of taxpayer money and thus unrealistic All US history teachers should read this book.



    16. A very good look at the presidents in terms of how they followed the constitution I would highly recommend this book to anyone who wants to get a constitutional look at the presidents.


    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *